Is your compost cold, slimy or smelly?
When a heap will not heat up, or turns slimy and smells, people reach for an activator, a turning fork or a new bin. The real cause is usually simpler. The mix has too much carbon or too much nitrogen.
In my biogeochemistry courses, carbon and nitrogen were the two elements that everything else depended on. We followed them through soil, plants and microbes. A compost heap is the same cycle in a small, fast version, and the carbon to nitrogen ratio, the C:N ratio, is the number that tells you how it will behave.
So here is what that number means, what the standard values are for the things you put in a bin, and how to use them.
What the C:N ratio is
It is the weight of carbon in a material divided by the weight of nitrogen. A ratio of 30:1 means 30 parts carbon for every 1 part nitrogen.
Why those two? According to Cornell’s composting pages on compost chemistry, microbes use carbon both as an energy source and as a building block for their cells, and they need nitrogen for proteins and enzymes. A heap works when the microbes have enough of both.
Brown, dry materials, such as leaves, are generally high in carbon. Green, moist materials, such as grass, are generally high in nitrogen. This is where the “browns and greens” advice comes from, and the C:N ratio is the maths behind it.
The target
Cornell gives the usual target as about 30:1 by weight. Oregon State University Extension, in its composting and the C:N ratio guide, gives a range of 25:1 to 40:1, with an average balance of about 30 parts carbon to 1 part nitrogen. My Compost Carbon:Nitrogen Ratio Calculator uses the same idea.
You do not need to hit 30 exactly. Think of it as a zone, not a point.
What happens when the ratio is wrong
Too high, too much carbon.
Cornell says higher ratios mean there is not enough nitrogen for the microbes to grow well. The heap stays cool and breaks down slowly. If your pile of leaves is just sitting there, this is the likely reason.
Too low, too much nitrogen. The extra nitrogen can be lost as ammonia gas, which gives the sharp smell people describe. I look at this in why does my compost smell.
Funny thing, both problems look like a failed heap, but the fixes are opposite. That is why the number is useful. It tells you whether to add leaves or add grass.
The carbon to nitrogen ratio of common materials
People ask about grass clippings more than any other material, so here is a table. The values are from the Cornell page, which cites published research, and they match Oregon State’s ranges.
| Material | Typical C:N ratio | What it is in a heap |
|---|---|---|
| Manure | 5 to 25 : 1 | Nitrogen-rich “green” |
| Vegetable scraps | 15 to 20 : 1 | Nitrogen-rich “green” |
| Grass clippings | 15 to 25 : 1 | Nitrogen-rich “green” |
| Coffee grounds | 20 : 1 | Nitrogen-rich “green” |
| Autumn leaves | 30 to 80 : 1 | Carbon-rich “brown” |
| Straw | 40 to 100 : 1 | Carbon-rich “brown” |
| Wood chips or sawdust | 100 to 500 : 1 | Carbon-rich “brown” |
| Newspaper or corrugated cardboard | about 560 : 1 | Carbon-rich “brown” |
Notice how wide some ranges are. A table value is an average, not a measurement of your own bucket, because age, moisture and what the plants were fed all change it.
The grass clippings answer, then, is that they are nitrogen-rich, at roughly 15 to 25 parts carbon to 1 part nitrogen. On their own they are too rich, so they need browns.
A worked example
Seeing the maths makes the idea click, so here it is with round numbers. They are assumptions, not measurements.
Take grass clippings at 20:1 and leaves at 50:1, both by dry weight, and assume that both are about 45 percent carbon, which is a typical figure for dry plant material. That puts the nitrogen at 2.25 percent in the grass and 0.9 percent in the leaves.
If you mix 1 kg of dry grass with 1.25 kg of dry leaves, the carbon is about 1.01 kg and the nitrogen about 0.034 kg. That is a ratio of about 30:1, right in the target zone.
So by dry weight, you need a little more leaves than grass. In a real bin the grass is wet and the leaves are fluffy, so the volumes look very different. That is the reason I do not ask anyone to weigh dry material. My Compost Green and Brown Balance guide, which I created for this, turns it into a simple mixing rule you can use by eye.
When the number alone can fool you
The C:N ratio counts all the carbon, but microbes cannot use all of it equally.
Cornell points out that some carbon is locked in resistant compounds. Newspaper, straw and corn stalks break down slowly, so a higher starting ratio can be planned for them. It also gives a lovely example: equal masses of wood chips and sawdust hold the same carbon, but sawdust has more surface area, so its carbon is far more available to microbes.
That is why a heap of big wood chips can behave as if it had far more nitrogen than the table suggests. Chop and shred your browns, and the table works better. These are published averages, so adjust by watching your own heap.
What the ratio does as compost matures
Cornell notes that the ratio falls from about 30:1 at the start to 10 to 15:1 in finished compost. Microbes release about two-thirds of the carbon they consume as carbon dioxide, which is the CO2 I wrote about in does compost release CO2. The carbon leaves, the nitrogen stays, and the ratio drops.
Soil itself usually sits in a similar low range, which is one reason finished compost blends well into a garden. I touch on soil life in how to tell if your soil is alive.
Why is the C:N ratio important in soil too?
Many people ask this next, so let me link the heap to the garden. In my biogeochemistry courses we followed the same ratio through soil, and the USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service explains the practical side in its soil tech note on the C:N ratio. It says that agricultural soil organic matter ideally averages about 10:1, which is close to the 10 to 15:1 of finished compost.
The note also explains what goes wrong when the ratio is too high. If you add a carbon-rich residue with too little nitrogen, the microbes will take nitrogen from the soil and lock it in their own tissues, which deprives growing plants of it. Low-nitrogen residues such as wheat straw take longer to decompose, while residues with ratios generally below 25:1, such as many cover crops, do not lock up nitrogen in the same way.
That is my reason for composting first. I would not dig a lot of fresh straw or wood chips into a bed where plants are growing, because that is the situation the note describes. It is my own reading of the note, not a tested rule for every garden. If you want to look at your soil, my Fix Your Garden Soil guide is where I go through it.

Which materials are high in carbon, and which in nitrogen?
People ask for examples more than anything else, so here is the short list from Cornell. High in carbon are autumn leaves, straw, wood chips and sawdust, bark at 100 to 130:1, mixed paper at 150 to 200:1, and newspaper or corrugated cardboard at about 560:1. High in nitrogen are grass clippings, plant cuttings, fruit and vegetable scraps, coffee grounds at about 20:1, and manure.
How do you add nitrogen to a heap? Cornell says that green and moist materials tend to be high in nitrogen, and it gives no special procedure beyond blending them with browns. The Oregon State guide takes the same route: add more greens. It also warns that lime raises the pH and can cause ammonia odour and nitrogen loss, and that wood ash should be used sparingly, no more than half a cup per five-gallon bucket.
How do I mix browns and greens by volume?
Most people do not weigh their scraps, and I do not blame them. The Oregon State guide suggests a starting blend of about two thirds browns to one third greens by volume, and a target of 25 to 40:1. I would start there and then adjust by watching the heap, using the symptoms I described above.
If you want to check a recipe, Oregon State gives a simple method. Multiply each material’s C:N ratio by its number of parts, add the results, and divide by the total number of parts. Its example uses 2 parts grass at 15, 1 part chicken manure at 15 and 1 part dry leaves at 70, which gives 115 divided by 4, or 28.75. That sits in the target zone. My calculator and my Green and Brown Balance guide do the same job without the arithmetic.

What about chicken, cow and goat manure?
Cornell lists manure as one row, at 5 to 25:1, and I did not find a university table that gives separate values for chicken, cow, horse or goat manure, so I will not quote one. The Oregon State guide uses 15 for chicken manure in its worked example, and it lists animal bedding mixed with manure at 30 to 80:1. So manure is nitrogen-rich, and the bedding can change the ratio a lot. I would treat it as a green and balance it with browns.
Does hot composting need a different ratio?
I did not find a separate ratio for hot composting in either Cornell or Oregon State. Both give the same target for composting in general, about 30:1, within a range of 25 to 40:1. Cornell gives no temperature targets. My own view is that heat depends on more than the ratio, since the moisture and the size of the heap also play a part, which is why a balanced mix is where I start.
How I use the numbers
Start with the materials you have. If it is autumn and you have leaves, add kitchen scraps or grass. If it is summer and you have clippings, add shredded cardboard or dry leaves.
Shred the browns. It makes the carbon available, as the sawdust example shows.
Fix by symptom. Cold and slow? Add nitrogen. Smelly and wet? Add carbon and air. Turning helps, and how often to turn compost explains when.
Choose nitrogen sources sensibly. A handful of fresh clippings is one option, and a concentrated nitrogen amendment is another. I compare two in bone meal vs blood meal, and the chemistry of fertiliser labels is in organic fertiliser chemistry and NPK labels.
Do not buy a fix for a ratio problem. I looked at whether activators help in do compost activators work, and a good mix does most of the job.
Use heat as your guide. A well-balanced, damp heap warms up, which I explain in hot vs cold composting.
Summary
The C:N ratio is the weight of carbon over the weight of nitrogen in a material. According to Cornell, about 30:1 is the usual target for composting, and Oregon State gives a range of 25:1 to 40:1. Too much carbon makes the heap cold and slow, and too much nitrogen can lose ammonia and smell.
Grass clippings are about 15 to 25:1, leaves 30 to 80:1, and sawdust 100 to 500:1. Carbon is not always available to microbes, so shred your browns. The ratio falls to 10 to 15:1 in finished compost. NRCS says agricultural soil organic matter ideally averages about 10:1, and carbon-rich residues with too little nitrogen make microbes take nitrogen from the soil.
FAQs
What is the ideal carbon to nitrogen ratio for compost?
About 30:1 by weight, according to Cornell. Oregon State Extension gives a range of 25:1 to 40:1, so think of it as a zone.
What is the carbon to nitrogen ratio of grass clippings?
About 15 to 25 parts carbon to 1 part nitrogen, which makes them nitrogen-rich. Mix them with browns such as dry leaves or shredded cardboard.
What happens if the C:N ratio is too high in compost?
There is not enough nitrogen for the microbes to grow, so the heap stays cool and breaks down slowly. Add nitrogen-rich greens.
What happens if the C:N ratio is too low?
The extra nitrogen can be lost as ammonia gas, which causes a sharp smell. Add carbon-rich browns and let air in.
What is the C:N ratio of finished compost?
About 10 to 15:1, according to Cornell. The ratio falls during composting because microbes release much of the carbon as CO2.
How do I calculate the carbon to nitrogen ratio of my compost?
I use the Oregon State method. Multiply each material’s ratio by its number of parts, add them up and divide by the total parts. Their example comes to 28.75.
What is the ratio of browns to greens by volume?
Oregon State suggests about two thirds browns to one third greens as a starting blend. I start there and adjust by watching the heap.
What is the C:N ratio of chicken manure?
I did not find a university table with a separate value. Oregon State uses 15 in a worked example, and Cornell lists manure at 5 to 25:1, so I treat it as nitrogen-rich.
What is the C:N ratio of cow or goat manure?
I did not find separate values for them either. Cornell gives 5 to 25:1 for manure in general, and I would balance it with browns.
Does hot composting need a different ratio?
I did not find a separate one. Cornell and Oregon State give the same target, about 30:1 within 25 to 40:1, and I would aim for that.
What is the ideal carbon to nitrogen ratio in soil?
NRCS says agricultural soil organic matter ideally averages about 10:1.
Why is the C:N ratio important in soil?
If a residue has too little nitrogen, NRCS says microbes will take nitrogen from the soil and lock it in their tissues, which deprives growing plants. That is why I compost carbon-rich material first.
How do I add nitrogen to compost?
Add nitrogen-rich greens such as grass clippings, plant cuttings or fruit and vegetable scraps. Cornell and Oregon State give no other procedure.
What materials are high in carbon for compost?
From Cornell’s list: autumn leaves, straw, wood chips, sawdust, bark, mixed paper and cardboard.
Do coffee grounds count as greens?
By the numbers, yes. Cornell lists coffee grounds at about 20:1, which puts them with the nitrogen-rich materials.
Can I put sawdust in compost?
Cornell lists it at 100 to 500:1, so it is very high in carbon. I would add it in thin layers with plenty of greens, because small particles make its carbon easier for microbes to use.
Is a 30:1 ratio always the best target?
Not always. Cornell calls it a useful goal that may need adjusting, and Oregon State gives a range of 25 to 40:1. Slowly breaking down materials such as straw need a higher starting ratio.
Is the C:N ratio overhyped?
I would say it is a good starting guide and not a rule. Carbon is not always available to microbes, so I use the numbers to plan and my own heap to decide.
Can I dig fresh straw or wood chips into my garden soil?
I would be careful. NRCS describes microbes taking nitrogen from the soil when a carbon-rich residue has too little nitrogen, which can starve growing plants. That is my own reading of it.













